Those who would stir
up anti-migrant feelings have recently taken to describing migrants being accommodated
in hotels as ‘men of fighting age’. There’s no universally-accepted definition
of ‘fighting age’, but broadly speaking most of us would probably think in
terms of 18-45 year olds. I haven’t seen any definitive statistics on the
question, but it is probably not unreasonable to assume that many of those
arriving (in small boats, in particular) do indeed fit that demographic. The
objective of using the term is clearly to encourage fear of the asylum-seekers.
There are some very
obvious reasons why the demographic would be slanted in that way, however, and
they’re nothing to do with a desire to terrorise the local population. It is
precisely the demographic likely to be targeted by the regimes they are fleeing
– whether as potential dissenters or even as potential soldiers. There is also
a natural human resistance to risking the lives of families with children; and
if a family wants to flee, who better to send as the ’advance party’ than those
perceived as being most likely to be able to establish themselves in the new
country.
That leads us to the
corollary of the ‘fighting men’ trope: that same group are also the most likely
to be capable of adding to the productive economy and the least likely – at least
until any other family members arrive – to be adding to demand on services such
as health, education and benefits. Allowed to work, even if only temporarily
whilst their asylum claims are processed, they would actually add to, rather
than subtract from, the economic health of the UK. Referring to them, more
accurately and usefully, as ‘men at their peak productive age’ would, of
course, have little effect on those determined to demonise them, but then those
who reach their political position on the basis of prejudices and priors are
never going to be swayed by mere facts anyway. It might, though, help to
encourage a more reasonable debate amongst those to whom facts continue to have
some salience.
No comments:
Post a Comment