Would Trump really bomb Tel Aviv?

Tweet

 

A few days ago, Trump gave Qatar an astonishing guarantee of security, promising that he would view any armed attack on the tiny energy-rich nation as a threat to the United States itself and be ready to take military action in defence of Qatar. Given that, in a way that I don’t pretend to fully understand, the ‘right to self-defence’ has somehow morphed in recent years into a right to mount a wholly disproportionate retaliatory attack, the pact must surely mean that anyone attacking Qatar should expect a massive response from the US military. And which country is most likely to launch a military attack on Qatar? Based on recent events, the most obvious answer is Israel.

Maybe Netanyahu has given Trump some sort of promise that he won’t do it again, so Trump doesn’t think the question will arise. But neither of them are exactly famous for keeping their word. A Trump promise to Qatar based on a Netanyahu promise to Trump doesn’t immediately strike me as a reliable basis for the security of anyone. In normal times, a $400 million bribe in the form of a free aeroplane might be enough to get something in return; but then again, in normal times, the idea of the President of the USA accepting a $400 million bribe would be unthinkable. One wonders what else Trump has extracted from Qatar in his latest protection racket payment for the defence pact. After all, the first bribe didn’t stop the US allowing Israel to bomb Doha (and even if Trump is personally and unprecedentedly telling the truth when he says that ‘he’ had no advance knowledge, the idea that the largest US base in the region wasn’t warned in advance is for the birds). There must surely be something else involved. Another golf course or hotel perhaps?

There is another aspect to Trump’s promise as well. If an attack on Qatar is treated the same as an attack on the US itself, does the NATO guarantee of mutual assistance extend to that circumstance as well? Has Trump effectively promised that the whole of NATO would attack Israel if another bomb were dropped on Doha? No, I don’t seriously believe that he has – although that doesn’t necessarily mean that he doesn’t think that he has. Whatever the Qataris have given Trump in exchange for this latest guarantee, they would be very foolish to depend on it ever being honoured.