Tuesday 1 October 2024

When does a gift become a tip, and therefore taxable?

 

A new law comes into force today regarding the distribution of tips in service industries. Some less than entirely scrupulous employers have been keeping all or part of the tips themselves rather than passing them on to employees. Whether tipping is a good thing or not is a matter of opinion; some of us would certainly prefer that the staff are paid a proper wage in the first place, even if that means prices go up a bit, rather than the staff being dependent on the arbitrary generosity of customers. Leaving that aside, tipping is currently a fact of life, but happens in two ways. Sometimes, cash goes directly into the hands of individual employees, but increasingly customers can choose to add an amount to the bill, and the total gets shared out and processed by the employer.

Tips have long been taxable (as the name suggests, income tax is a tax on income, not just on earnings), and one advantage of employers doing the collection and paying is that the tax can be, and generally is, processed through the employers’ PAYE systems. Cash put directly in the hands of individual staff members, however, is only taxed if it is properly declared to HMRC, and there must be at least some doubt as to how much gets declared in practice. As a general rule, ‘gifts’ are not taxable (although there are exceptions, especially when gifting is used as a means of attempting to avoid paying tax), but ‘gifts’ received by an employee as a result of his or her employment – which is what tips effectively are – are unquestionably taxable, although it does open up something of a grey area.

It made me wonder, though: if gifts received as a result of the job a person does (i.e. they would not be received by the same person if he or she were doing a different job) are taxable, why are gifts received by MPs not subject to income tax? It is clear that they effectively boost the spending power (and thus the ‘real’ income) of the recipients and that they are only given because of the job the individuals are doing, so why are they not treated as income? Why should a waiter earning at or around the minimum wage, say, who receives a tenner at the end of a meal, have to pay 20% tax on it, whilst a person on a substantial salary who receives clothing worth £30,000, to pick a recent example at random, pays nothing? It wouldn’t be a huge money-spinner in the scale of things, but if the Chancellor is serious about closing loopholes on tax avoidance and clamping down on benefit fraud, perhaps she should also look a little closer to home at the people around her.

No comments: