Tuesday, 29 October 2024

Labour's anti-colonialist delusionists

 

A few Labour MPs have criticised their leader in the past few days for his imperialist stance on the question of reparations for slavery. To listen to them speak, one might think that the Labour Party is a bastion of anti-imperialism and anti-colonialism. They’re deluded – the Labour Party is as much an English imperialist-minded party as the Tories. That’s how we are allowed to have elections in the UK: by ensuring that nothing changes very much. If it wasn’t obvious to the ‘rebels’ previously, surely the half-hearted handover of only part of the Chagos Islands whilst retaining the UK’s ‘right’ to Diego García ought to have opened their eyes at least a little.

It isn’t only in relation to reparations that the imperialist mindset operates; it also underlies the nonsense that the UK is a major world power which can threaten (or maybe create) adversaries across the globe. To say nothing, of course, about the continued possession of nuclear weapons. Starmer has been at it again this week, telling Iran that it must not respond to Israel’s ‘retaliation’, and that Iran and the Palestinians must allow Israel to have the last word – or last airstrike, more accurately – in the current tit-for-tat round of violence. Why either should listen to a state which is the former colonial ruler of Palestine and which has a history of using force to secure the economic interests of its capitalists in Iran (and which itself therefore bears no small historical responsibility for the situation in the Middle East) is a question which only a died-in-the-wool imperialist wouldn’t even think to ask. That we need a ceasefire and proper peace talks with the serious intention of seeking a just settlement goes without saying; that the conflict can be ended by the historical school yard bullies telling one side to desist is as delusional as believing Labour to be inherently anti-colonial.

No comments: