Showing posts with label Cameron. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Cameron. Show all posts

Thursday, 25 April 2024

Post-imperial incomprehension

 

Posh Boy Cameron spends a lot of his time swanning around telling other countries what they must or must not do. Most recently, Israel and Iran have received the benefit of his wisdom and advice, and have particularly been urged to remain calm rather than fight each other. Whilst I can’t disagree with the sentiment that it would be better if armies and armed groups weren’t killing each other along with any civilians who happen to get in the way, or even look askance at the men with guns, I can’t help but wonder if he has the remotest idea of how such advice, coming from such a person, is likely to sound to those being advised.

It’s hard to deal with complex history in a few short sentences, but in essence, Israel is a state that was born from a terrorist campaign against the colonial power at the time – which was, of course, the British Empire. Iran’s status as a theocratic Islamic state came about as a result of a revolt against the then Shah, a monarch who gained absolute power after the democratic government was overthrown by the CIA and British-backed army in order to protect British oil interests in the country. And the successor state to the British Empire, namely the UK, has, like its predecessor, a long history of violent intervention in the wider region in pursuit of its own, largely economic, interests. In short, neither country has much reason to look back on past British actions in the region with what one might call fondness, let alone see it as some sort of role model.

The idea that a recycled Old Etonian has-been who somehow managed to accidentally lead his own country out of the world’s largest and most successful trading bloc is somehow the ideal person to act on behalf of the wider world in delivering desist messages to two former imperial possessions (or semi-possessions) would seem strange to anyone who isn’t suffering from Post Imperial Stress Disorder (PISD), with its associated requirement to give the impression of being a great power in a position to deliver instructions to lesser mortals. A category which includes all foreigners in general. He genuinely seems not to comprehend why his instructions to the natives are not being followed, but that incomprehension is just another symptom of the disorder.

Friday, 5 January 2024

Weird mathematics and losing the plot

 

When he says that the Rwanda Bill will “get the job {of stopping the boats} done”, Lord Cameron may just be saying what he knows that he has to say in order to display loyalty to the PM and keep his job. Unprincipled and cowardly, for sure – but we already knew that about him anyway. Alternatively, he may even believe what he says, which would merely make him too stupid to hold high office. But I think we already knew that too. There is no explanation for his words which is going to leave him looking good, but that, again, is hardly something new. The only reason that he isn’t widely known as the worst UK PM ever is the four who have followed him in the job.

Back in the real world, whilst we don’t know exactly how much capacity Rwanda has for taking asylum-seekers from the UK, all the reports suggest that the total is in the low hundreds annually. Even if we assume that the reduction to around 30,000 last year in the numbers arriving by small boats is a ‘real’ reduction rather than largely a product of weather conditions, knowing that a maximum of around 1% are likely to be sent to Rwanda seems unlikely to be the all-powerful deterrent as which the government present it. Not for those who have a basic understanding of arithmetic anyway – which is a considerably higher proportion of asylum-seekers than it is of government ministers. And, to the apparent surprise of those ministers, many of the asylum-seekers can and do read news reports which suggest that more than 80% of them are likely to be granted asylum status eventually, whilst the Home Office will simply (and conveniently, if the objective is to reduce the numbers) lose track of many of the remainder, who will quietly disappear into the UK’s black economy. Unless they're planning detention camps on a large scale. Working out whether ‘80% plus’ is a higher number than ‘less than 1%’ isn’t exactly what my maths teacher used to call a ‘hard sum’ for most of us, but government ministers are clearly trained in some form of alternative mathematics. Presumably to complement the alternative facts which they brandish so readily.

Meanwhile, Farage’s limited company, pretending to be a political party called Reform, has come up with the suggestion that the answer to controlling the numbers of immigrants is to impose a policy of “one in, one out”, under which no-one would be allowed into the UK until after someone else has left. The implications for care and health services, to say nothing of fruit-picking, are not spelled out, but it wouldn’t be at all surprising if the ‘success’ of this policy depended on an approach similar to that outlined by the Deputy Chair of the Tory Party a few years ago: rounding up those declared to be a nuisance, putting them in tents and forcing them to harvest vegetables and fruit. Others have suggested that pensioners should be obliged to do community or care work, or else lose part of their pensions. Directed or forced labour coupled with detention camps would seem to be the logical conclusion of the policy, but given past history the reluctance to say so is understandable.

Some Tories have suggested that, rather than allowing immigrants to fill job vacancies, the government should be encouraging people to have larger families to provide a future source of labour. Leaving aside any sustainability considerations surrounding population increases, to say nothing of the minor inconvenience that there is at least a 20-year lead time on this approach to solving labour shortages, it does nothing to answer the basic problem – as repeatedly outlined by the government – that immigration is leading to a shortage of houses, places in schools and health facilities. Whether the population increases because of migration or an increasing birth rate is irrelevant – an increase in population requires more facilities. And that is the lie at the heart of the anti-migrant rhetoric: it isn’t migration which causes the shortage, but government failure to plan for and provide the resources to match the needs of a growing population. Blaming migrants is just misdirection.

Perhaps Sunak has some polling data which hasn’t been made more widely available; maybe there really is a large number of people who will suddenly return to the Tory fold if they can see a tiny number of migrants being manhandled in chains onto aircraft destined for Central Africa. But it doesn’t seem to match publicly available data. And pinning so many of his hopes on a policy which seems destined to fail, even if it doesn’t destroy his own party first, looks like the action of a man who has completely lost the plot.

Monday, 12 April 2021

The way things work

 

Some years ago, when I was working as an IT Project Manager, I went for an interview for a similar job with another company. From their advert, they seemed to be seeking exactly the experience which I could offer – a match which turned out to be far from accidental. At the interview, it rapidly became clear that they were looking to do business with my, then, current employer, and weren’t in the least interested in what I thought was my brilliant skillset and experience in the field, only in who I knew and what doors I could open for them. The advert had been worded specifically to attract applicants from the staff of the company which employed me at the time. Charitably, I marked it down to experience and a misunderstanding, and moved on.

I doubt that there was anything as formal as an interview involved when David Cameron was appointed to his nice little earner at Greensill. But whatever appointment processed was used, he can surely have been under no delusion that he was being sought out for any presumed skills or experience in the world of finance, because even he must be sufficiently self-aware to realise that he possesses neither. They wanted him – and appointed him – for one thing only: his contacts in government and his supposed ability as a consequence to get the company preferential access and preferential treatment. His messages to the Chancellor, his cosy chat with the Health Secretary – this bypassing of official channels in pursuit of favours was exactly what he was being paid for, and he seems to have been quite assiduous in carrying out his duties, even if, ultimately, rather less than entirely successful.

This is, of course, as my own experience on a much smaller scale attests, simply the way things work. It’s not the exception, it’s the norm. Mutual back scratching and the Old Boy network still hold sway over vast areas of business and politics in the UK. The really strange thing is that so many people seem to believe that the Cameron affair is some sort of newsworthy exception, and that meritocracy is the norm. But the only thing that’s truly different about the current government is that they’re so blatant and shameless about it all.

Tuesday, 16 April 2019

Avoiding a vote


Brexit started life as a wizard wheeze by David Cameron to silence the awkward squad in his own party.  Cunning Plan A was to promise them an ‘in-out’ referendum in the hope that the awkward squad would simply shut up and allow him to get on with the serious business of government without the perpetual whingeing about Europe.  Besides, he ‘knew’ that he wasn’t going to win the election outright and therefore would never have to deliver; his coalition partners would simply veto the referendum.  The plan went badly wrong when his party accidentally won more seats than he had anticipated, leaving him in a position where the only way of maintaining any semblance of party unity was to attempt to actually deliver on his commitment.
Plan A might not have exactly worked out, but not to worry; not-quite-so-cunning Plan B was to breeze over to Brussels, pretend to negotiate a bit, gain a few minor concessions, and then hold a referendum.  He ‘knew’ that the EU was just sitting there waiting to give yet more special terms to the UK, and he ‘knew’ that he was going to get a thumping majority for Remain.  He then hoped that the awkward squad would simply shut up and allow him to get on with the serious business of government without the perpetual whingeing about Europe.  His ability to predict, let alone control, the outcome of a public vote proved as reliable as ever, and Plan B also bit the dust.  His Plan C was not really cunning at all – scarper and leave someone else to clear up the mess.
It was left to his successor to come up with Plan D.  After a period of umming and ahing, and after having kicked off the process of triggering Article 50 without a clue as to the end point, she decided that the way to get around her internal party divisions was to hold another general election.  Displaying the same acute predictive ability for which her predecessor was, rightly, not at all famous, she ‘knew’ that she would win a large enough majority to be able to silence the awkward squad and allow her to get on with the serious business of government without the perpetual whingeing about Europe.   Plan D went the same way as Plans A and B.  At this point, she might have been best advised to revisit Plan C, which was the only one that actually worked for her predecessor, but instead she came up with the ill-fated Plan E. 
Plan E was the transparently uncunning approach of telling both sides of her own party, repeatedly and in public, that if they didn't do as she wished the other side would win in the hope that neither would be clever enough to work out that she was actually proposing a route which none of them supported.  She might even have got away with it, if she’d opted for a short, sharp and decisive negotiation immediately after the election whilst MPs were still shell-shocked enough to have simply voted it through.  However, when thinking about Theresa May, ‘decisive’ isn’t exactly the first word that jumps into mind. 
In fairness, though, there is one thing that the PM has learnt from the common factor in the failure of Plans A, B, and D, and it is this: for a Tory PM with a Plan, allowing people to vote is a very, very bad idea.  The people have developed an unfortunate habit of not producing the answer that the Tories want.  Thus we arrive at today’s news, in which the Foreign Secretary tells us that the absolute top priority for the Government is to prevent the European Parliament elections from taking place in the UK.  Not to look after the economic interests of the people they represent, not to end the shambolic process which they have kicked off, not to sort out problems with health or education.  No, just to prevent people having a vote in an election which might not – and probably would not – produce the answer that they want.  If the elections take place, the probability is that the Tories will be badly mauled (or even ‘marmalized’, according to some).  They don’t have a policy on which they can agree, and even if they did, there’s no guarantee that those elected would support it.  At best, half the members elected from one of the parties would be supportive of the May deal, and the rest from that party, and all those from other parties, would be against it.  Allowing a vote, in whatever proxy form, on her plan is almost certain to show how little support it has.
That, of course, brings us right back to the beginning.  Avoiding an election is, just like the original conception of Brexit, all about the Tory Party.  It is, though, already far too late to silence the awkward squad.  It’s a lost cause; continuing to fight yesterday’s battles may be the prime interest of some of the awkward squad, but it’s already way too late to restore any semblance of unity to a disintegrating party.

Wednesday, 28 November 2018

Desperate measures


The Prime Minister is showing very obvious signs of increasing desperation in her demands that we all believe and ‘get behind’ her lies and obfuscation in order to make ourselves worse off.  It’s hardly surprising; even the thought of trying to do that is enough to make anyone desperate.  But how desperate does someone have to be to believe that Michael Gove is some sort of ‘secret weapon’?  She can’t even be entirely certain that he knows which side he’s supposed to be on, given his clear reservations about her dodgy deal, and his proven tendency towards backstabbing in relation to those who seek his support.  Still, it’s perhaps not quite as desperate as the idea that the solution to the problem is to bring back the man who caused it in the first place.  Now that really would be a silly thing to do - so it will probably become official policy shortly.

Tuesday, 7 August 2018

Determining lunacy


According to the Sunday Times (paywall), David Cameron concluded during the run-up to the EU referendum that the then Justice Secretary and Lord Chancellor, Michael Gove was ‘mad’ and ‘behaving like a lunatic’.  I’m not in a position to judge – the fact that he sometimes looks a bit mad is far from adequate grounds to draw any conclusion.  But Cameron appointed him to the job, and should have been in a better position to make a judgement than I.
Mildly amusing though it is to see Tories falling out amongst themselves, not just over policy but in such a highly personal fashion as well, it surely raises as many questions about Cameron as it does about Gove.  After all, if the Prime Minister had really come to the conclusion that his Justice Secretary was as mad as a box of frogs, why on earth did he leave him in charge of the Department of Justice?  It doesn't look like the action of a responsible Prime Minister.
Perhaps Cameron wasn’t preparing to sell an otherwise boring book back then…

Thursday, 15 September 2016

Winging it

The report of the House of Commons Foreign Affairs Committee on the intervention in Libya contained a damning indictment of the former Prime Minister, David Cameron according to all the newspaper reports.  In some ways, though, it’s a pity that the investigation and report were limited to the issue of Libya.
At one point, the report said that “…former prime minister David Cameron was ultimately responsible for the failure to develop a coherent Libya strategy”.  It struck me that the sentence would still ring true if the word ‘Libya’ was deleted.  The debacle over Brexit, for instance, was a result of the same tendency – a lack of a coherent strategy and a tendency to fly by the seat of his pants, making it up as he went along.  Overconfidence in one’s own ability to ‘wing it’ is not a sound basis for good government.  In the case of Libya, it probably led to many needless deaths as well.

Tuesday, 13 September 2016

What next for Cameron?

After resigning his parliamentary seat yesterday, Cameron said that his continued presence would be a ‘distraction’ from the work of his successor, and appeared to make it clear that he did not want to be in a position of putting an alternative point of view to that of the government.  However, he also said that ‘he wants to continue in public service and campaign on the domestic and international causes that he championed in Downing Street’.  I wonder how he squares that particular circle.
There was another piece of analysis yesterday by the BBC’s Political Editor, looking at how completely May has junked the people and policies of the Cameron era.  We’ve had a complete overturning of the economic policy which Cameron, Osborne, (and, I’m sure, even May) previously told us were essential.  International policy (towards China in particular) looks likely to see significant change.  This week, policy on selective education was reversed.  It seems that the so-called ‘northern powerhouse’ so beloved of the ex-Chancellor is rather less close to the hearts of the new team as well – and all this in just two months.  Who knows what else will change as she really gets stuck in?
The comment ("it IS a new government", one senior Tory told me, "not everyone has understood that yet") reported in the second story seemed quite accurate to me.  We have a new government, working to a new and different set of priorities.  Whilst the changes are not necessarily in the same direction, the difference between a May administration and a Cameron one looks like being as great – perhaps even greater – than the difference that there would have been between a Cameron administration and a Miliband administration had the 2015 election gone the other way.  And all achieved without the bother and hassle of an election.
But back to Cameron: given the extent of the emerging differences, how can he continue to campaign for the same things without ending up in opposition to May’s government?

Tuesday, 24 May 2016

Another day, another wild claim

It’s beginning to look as though neither side in the debate about the EU referendum can allow a single day to go by without producing more inflated and sensational claims about the effects of either remaining or leaving.
Today we have a warning from Cameron about the cost of European family holidays.  Reading the headlines, one could be forgiven for believing that this is a proven fact – which is, of course, what Cameron wants us to believe – but in fact it’s little more than a back-of-an-envelope calculation based on an unsubstantiated assertion about the impact of Brexit on the value of the pound in the immediate aftermath of an exit vote.  So how valid is the assertion?
It does seem probable that Brexit would lead to an immediate short term drop in the value of the pound on international markets.  That’s partly based on those people trading in currency believing the gloomy predictions, and partly on them seeing the gloomy predictions as an opportunity to bet against the pound and make some money.  Whether such a fall in value would be sustained is a much more difficult question to answer.
But if indeed, it turned out that the new ‘normal’ value of the pound was indeed lower for an extended period, then the claim that it would increase the price of holidays would be a valid one.  But not just in Europe, of course; a lower pound would increase the cost of holidays anywhere where people need to pay for things in a currency other than sterling.  And indeed, Cameron could legitimately have gone on to say that, assuming his guesstimates are right, any goods or services purchased from ‘abroad’ would be more expensive. 
That’s only half the equation, though – because whilst a cheaper pound would make foreign purchases more expensive, it would also make foreign sales more competitive.  A fall in the value of the pound isn’t necessarily a wholly bad thing, and as well as exaggerating on the basis of broad unsubstantiated assumptions, Cameron is also guilty of gross over-simplification of a complex question in an attempt to appeal to people to vote on the basis of a very narrow interpretation of their own self-interest.
As a supporter of the 'remain' campaign, I find the arguments being made in favour to be increasingly disappointing.  I almost wonder if some of them might actually want to lose. 

Wednesday, 18 May 2016

War, peace, hyperbole, and Euro-poker

Perhaps it’s something to do with the nature of their education, but it seems in recent days as though Cameron and Johnson have been trying to reduce the debate about the EU referendum to a game of common-room poker in which they try to outbid each other with horrendous consequences if we take the ‘wrong’ decision.
Cameron started it, when he said something along the lines of “I bet World War Three”.
Johnson: “I’ll see your World War Three and raise you a Hitler and a Napoleon”.
Cameron: “I’ll see your Hitler and Napoleon, and raise you an ISIS”.
It might be mildly amusing to watch if they were just playing cards, but they’re not – the real stake here is the future direction of a continent, and it would be reasonable to expect all of those involved to try and keep a sense of perspective in laying out their arguments.
It’s certainly true that part of the vision of those involved in setting up what has become the EU was that the major European powers should never go to war with each other again, and that the best way of preventing that would be to enmesh their economies irrevocably.  It’s also true that, for the last 70 years, the peace has held between countries which spent large parts of the previous few centuries at war with each other.  Whether there was cause and effect here is rather harder to determine.  If countries have reached a point where they recognise that they need to stop invading each other on a regular cycle, perhaps they no longer need the formal institutions to prevent it.  Perhaps; we can never be certain what might otherwise have happened, yet the certainty with which politicians pronounce on this point is alarming.
The comparison with Hitler and Napoleon is a ludicrous one.  A Europe united by conquest by one state or another – such as France or Germany in this case – is not at all the same thing as a Europe united by discussion and agreement between partners, and it’s nonsense to suggest that it is.  The ‘unifying’ intent of Hitler or Napoleon is better compared with the process by which the individual ‘unified’ current states of Europe – such as France, Germany, and, yes, the UK – were themselves created in centuries gone by than with the process by which a united Europe has been built.
As for ISIS welcoming Brexit – well maybe they would, maybe they wouldn’t.  The aim of a united caliphate which they are pursuing by bloodshed and fear certainly puts them more in the Hitler and Napoleon camp than the Monnet camp of history; but merely avoiding doing what a perceived enemy might want us to do doesn’t strike me as a particularly brilliant line of argument.  Trying to do the opposite of what someone else wants us to do because he’s not our friend is more kindergarten stuff.
It would be nice to think that the standard of debate might improve as the referendum approaches – but it seems more likely to degenerate further.

Thursday, 14 April 2016

Do they think we're stupid?

The party currently calling itself the “Welsh Conservatives” have kindly sent me a leaflet this week urging me to vote for the ‘Local Candidate’ on one ballot and ‘Welsh Conservatives’ on the other.  They don’t, however, seem to think it either necessary or appropriate to tell me who any of these people are. 
There are lots of photos in the leaflet, although it’s far from clear whether any of them are candidates in the election.  There are four pictures that I recognise - David Cameron, Jeremy Corbyn, Andrew RT Davies and Carwyn Jones – but the rest look like stock photos.  Of the four, only two are actually named.  Apparently, Jeremy Corbyn wants me to vote for him for another five years to make the same mistakes, whereas David Cameron is delivering economic security.  But neither of them are actually in power at the moment nor will they be on the ballot paper for the election. 
The leaflet also proclaims rather boldly that Labour hold 30 seats in the Assembly and that if they lose just one seat they lose power.  Do they really believe that themselves?  Two possibilities strike me; the first is that they really do, in which case their understanding of Welsh politics and the electoral system is, shall we say, a little shaky; and the second is that they don’t believe it, but they think that I (and other electors) will be stupid enough to fall for the lie.
Still, credit where credit’s due – at least it’s bilingual nonsense, which is a huge step forward from a lot of the past efforts of the Tories.

Wednesday, 13 April 2016

Tax returns - who cares?

In refusing to release his income tax details, UKIP’s leader in Wales said that he thought that the rush by other leaders to release theirs was a bit of ‘grandstanding’.  His refusal succeeds in making him look a little shady, but the comment is one of the few things he’s ever said with which I agree.  A question about whether the Prime Minister has gained from the tax avoidance benefits of an off-shore arrangement has been diverted into a competition between politicians to see who can appear to be the whitest.  And the original question has been completely lost in the process.
I’m not particularly interested in seeing politicians’ tax returns.  All they really tell us is that the individuals concerned have paid the correct amount of tax on the income that they’ve declared.  That should surprise no-one; it’s actually very difficult to avoid paying tax on income once it’s declared.  HMRC may have its faults, and they may sometimes struggle with the arithmetic, but the formula for calculating tax is straightforward, and once the income is properly declared, they will eventually get it right.  It strikes me as highly unlikely that any tax return published by any politician is ever going to get that wrong.
But the question asked of Cameron wasn’t whether he had paid tax on the income received; it was whether he’d ever benefited from a tax avoidance scheme.  Whilst it seems clear that he has paid all the tax due by him personally on the monies received, it remains the case that a company incorporated off-shore was able to avoid paying a penny in corporation tax for many years (even if, as the PM claims, that was never the prime objective of the off-shore arrangement).  It is probably reasonable to assume that not having to pay tax on company profits allows a company to accumulate profit at a faster rate than an equivalent company incorporated elsewhere, and therefore that the beneficiaries of the arrangement ultimately gain from the tax-free status.  That, I thought, was the original question, but it seems to have been lost in the rumpus over tax returns – a good indicator of why ‘hue and cry’ is not the best way of dealing with complex issues.
But let’s get back to the question of tax returns.  ‘Tax returns’ is being used as some sort of cypher to assess the openness and transparency of politicians (which is why, although he may have a good point, the refusal of UKIP’s Welsh leader to release his makes him look dodgy).  But what do we really need to know about politicians and money?  Fundamentally, it seems to me that there is only one relevant issue.  In essence, that is the source of their income and wealth, so that we can judge whether any decisions that they take are likely to be influenced by considerations of personal advantage, or to what extent, as a corollary, they are able to benefit personally from the rules that they change (or fail to change) whilst others are not.  If the rules on declarations of interest aren’t good enough to ensure that, then they need to be changed; tax returns don’t actually add much useful information.  And anyway, if someone is dishonest enough to make an incomplete declaration of interest, why would anyone expect that they’d then tell HMRC the truth?

Friday, 8 April 2016

Legality and morality

The Panama Papers have highlighted for me an increasing trend amongst politicians, bankers etc. to transfer all responsibility for deciding on the morality of a given action to the legislators in parliament.  Anything which isn’t specifically illegal is thus automatically deemed acceptable.  The phrase “no wrongdoing” is glibly equated with “no criminal activity”. 
The law company at the centre of the scandal has gone one step further in defending itself by drawing attention to the fact that it’s never been charged with any offences in 40 years of activity.  True, but the parallel which came to mind was with a very successful bank robber who’s never been caught.  Never having been caught isn’t at all the same thing as never having committed any criminal acts, yet that seems to be the essence of their defence.
Cameron in particular is squirming under the pressure, and rightly so given his previous condemnation of others for similar activities.  His latest line – that the infamous trust wasn’t set up to avoid tax, merely to allow trading in dollar-denominated securities – is an attempt to tell us that the tax-avoiding consequences of the decision to set up the trust in that way are merely some sort of ‘incidental’ result of an action taken for an otherwise entirely proper reason.  Perhaps from his perspective that sounds credible, but I doubt that many will be convinced. 
It’s bad enough when the bankers fall back on the simplistic equation of morality and law, but for ministers and legislators, it’s a much bigger problem – because, after all, they’re the ones who make the law.  For them to defend an action on the basis that they themselves haven’t actually legislated to outlaw it simply doesn’t wash; rather, it makes the offence worse.
It’s probably unreasonable to expect that legislators and ministers, drawn as they are on an almost random basis from the population, will be on average any more honest or less venal than those outside parliament.  And given the electoral processes, there is no easy way for the electors to keep them honest, not least because there can never be any guarantee that any replacements will be any better than those they replace.  But we can and should challenge the simplistic assumption that morality and legality are one and the same thing.  And especially so in the case of those making the laws.

Monday, 14 March 2016

Financial black holes

London’s Mayor has done his best today to ‘warn off’ Obama from intervening in the EU referendum by expressing the clear preference of the US for the UK to remain a member.  I’m not sure how good an idea it is for Cameron to be orchestrating such support for his position from his friends abroad.  Personally, I suspect that it is likely to be counter-productive on the whole.
Whatever, as part of his comments, Johnson came out with this gem: "There is no country in the world that defends its own sovereignty with such hysterical vigilance as the United States of America.  This is a nation born from its glorious refusal to accept overseas control."
It’s a very poor comparison with the question of EU membership of course – the UK gets more of a say in the affairs of the EU than it ever wanted to allow the citizens of the US.  Political rhetoric only needs to sound good, though.
But it also reminded me of this piece on Wings Over Scotland last week, drawing attention to the arguments of those who opposed independence for the US, on the grounds that they couldn’t afford it.  However, the ‘refusal to accept overseas control’ proved stronger than that.  And for a poor and hopelessly dependent economy, things didn’t turn out so badly in the end.
On the other hand, if they’d had to wait until they could produce a budget showing that they really could be self-sufficient – the bar set by many for Wales and Scotland – they’d probably still be waiting.  And no doubt the opponents of American independence would now be pointing to the latest figures claiming that there was a $544 billion black hole in the plans of those demanding independence, just like they’re doing in the case of Scotland at present.
The point?  Simply that the willingness to accept responsibility is the important factor.  Our future is ultimately what we make it.

Tuesday, 1 March 2016

A question of trust

One of the points made frequently by those who wish to see the UK leave the EU is that the ‘European’ funds which areas such as Wales receive aren’t really European at all; they’re just UK funds cycled through Brussels.  On this basis, the argument goes, any UK government outside the EU could simply give the money directly to Wales and cut out the middle man.
The logic of that is inescapable, and the usual counter argument is that whilst it may theoretically be true, the UK government could not be depended on to do that.  I agree with that as well in practice, but boiling the issue down to who we trust least means that it isn’t really an economic argument at all.
Last week, when he was in Wales, Cameron himself made it clear that he could not and would not guarantee to replace EU funding with equivalent UK funding in the event of a UK exit.  It was refreshingly honest, but I can’t help feeling that it’s rather strange for any politician, and perhaps especially for a Prime Minister, to try and win any argument by saying, in effect, “You can’t trust me”.  It’s a strange world sometimes.

Monday, 22 February 2016

Halfway in, halfway out?

Cameron’s return from Brussels with his agreement on ‘special status’ for the UK reminded me of the old story about the trade union negotiator who came back to his members and told them that he had good news and bad news.  “The bad news,” he said, “is that I haven’t been able to get us a pay rise.  In fact, I’ve had to agree to a pay cut.  But the good news is that I’ve managed to get it back-dated.”
Cameron seems quite pleased with himself for having got a deal in which he’s not only not achieved what he set out to achieve, but if we believe what he says, he may well have succeeded in reducing UK influence on key decisions in the future, by placing the UK outside the inner circle, as a sort of ‘half-member’ of the EU.  Thankfully:
·         ‘half-membership’ won’t be on the ballot paper for the referendum – if it was, it might be something that I’d have real difficulty supporting, and
·         he’s cynically misrepresenting what he’s achieved. 
He might want to present it, for his own political ends, as being a step halfway out, but the reason that the other 27 have agreed it is that it’s a lot less significant than that.  Does anyone really believe that they’d agree to a whole new class of membership applied to one state only and still allow that state to have the same amount of clout in decision-making as the others?
They’re happy for him to present it as he wishes, but they probably suspect that they’ll be able to row back even on what little has been agreed after a change of government in London at some future date.  That would be entirely in line with the long-standing pragmatism of the whole institution.

Monday, 25 January 2016

Applying double standards

Last week, a report was published suggesting strongly that the murder of Alexander Litvinenko was ordered at the very highest level in the Kremlin, probably by Putin himself.  The response of the UK Government succeeded in exposing a classic application of double standards.
The Government of country A ordered the use of a deadly radioactive substance to eliminate one of its former citizens who was resident in country B because it regarded him as a traitor and a danger to the country’s security.  According to the Prime Minister of country B, one David Cameron, this is an outrage against international law requiring sanctions against country A.
However, not so very long ago, the Government of country B ordered the firing of a missile from a drone to eliminate one of its former citizens (and anyone standing too close to him at the time) who was resident in country C because it regarded him as a terrorist and a danger to the country’s security.  According to the Prime Minister of country B, the same David Cameron, this is an entirely justified act of self defence.
Now, of course, the two situations aren’t entirely identical, and of course I’ve simplified things to highlight the similarities.  But in both cases, governments have resorted to extra-judicial killing to dispose of people that they can’t get to otherwise, and no government which is prepared to resort to such measures can really have very good grounds to criticise another which behaves in the same way.
Cameron is always banging on about British values.  I’ve noted before that I really don’t understand exactly what those values are or what makes them specifically British; but insofar as I do understand the claimed values of the West, I don’t remember them ever including the use of extra-judicial killing, or of the application of double standards.  Sometimes, people’s real values are more obvious from their actions than their words.

Monday, 4 January 2016

Dangerous jingoism

The Prime Minister’s New Year’s message was widely published with many newspapers using such similar wording that it can surely only have been lifted directly from a Downing Street press release.  The reports all seem to start as follows:
David Cameron has promised to crack down on Islamic State (IS) sympathisers, stressing in a New Year's message that all Britons should have "loyalty" to their country.
The Prime Minister said 2016 would be a "test of our mettle" as he pledged action to tackle the "poisonous narrative" which led some Britons to turn against their country.
He said the UK should "revel" in its way of life rather than "appease" extremists, and all who live in the country must sign up to its values.
But what does the ‘loyalty’ that he demands that we all show really amount to?  Loyalty to what, or to whom?  And what does he mean when he says that ‘all who live in the country must sign up to its values’?  Without a lot more definition, this is just meaningless rhetoric – but there is a danger in letting it go unchallenged.
The idea of ‘my country, right or wrong’ is one which I reject absolutely; such jingoism has, historically, been a disastrous creed.  From Cameron’s perspective, I guess that means that I will fail any loyalty test that he is likely to set.  I don’t think that I’m alone in that.  I know that my values are not the same as his either (even though he has proved singularly unable to articulate them effectively).  I guess that I’ll fail that test as well.
The history of states and leaders demanding that people show ‘loyalty’ and ‘sign up’ to a set of values isn’t exactly a happy one.  A narrative which appears to demand such loyalty is as poisonous, albeit in a different way, as the specific narrative which he is condemning.  It’s a demand for a degree of conformity which will be anathema to many.  It is dangerous for any democracy to allow extreme views such as those being expressed by Cameron to go unchallenged, let alone become the accepted norm.

Tuesday, 15 December 2015

What sort of future for Wales?

There were two stories in the media on Monday about Wales and the forthcoming EU referendum, both of which featured His Unroyal Hainness prominently.  I almost felt a little sorry for him after reading the first one, which said that he had been formally unveiled by Carwyn Jones, as though he were some sort of statue or commemorative plaque.  (Although, come to think of it, perhaps the comparison is not entirely without merit…)
The second was a reference to an article written by Hain and the Welsh Labour MEP, Derek Vaughan about the issues at stake in the referendum.  The headline was a little over the top, I thought.  “The very future of Wales is at stake” implies that somehow Wales might cease to exist if the vote goes the wrong way, as though we will somehow be wiped from the map.  But I suppose that a more realistic “Wales’ future outside the EU would not be the same as its future inside the EU” lacks in impact what it makes up for in truth.
Overall, the article was hugely disappointing.  Firstly, that was because so much of it concentrated on the argument that jobs depend on the EU.  I simply don’t accept that argument as being true – and I’m amongst those who want to stay in the EU.  It’s facile, and based on an assumption that the economy wouldn’t adapt to a new context.
The second issue that they spent many words discussing is the question of immigration.  Arguing that it’s easier to control immigration as a member than it would be outside is an obvious attempt to appeal to those who want out because of immigration, but the basis of their argument looks decidedly dodgy to me.  And even if they were right, the idea that the referendum on the EU is about the best way to control immigration is a long way short of putting a positive case for the EU.
Many of the advantages that they do mention – such as employee rights – don’t actually require the existence of the EU; they are things that any half-decent UK Government could have done anyway.  And there’s something very depressing about Labour politicians arguing that UK Governments, even of their own party, have only introduced such measures because the EU told them to.  That’s pretty close to conceding the case being put by opponents of membership that all these regulations have been ‘imposed’ on unwilling UK governments by ‘Brussels’.
We’re only having a referendum at all because of internal divisions within the Tory party.  A tactic adopted by Cameron to try and retain control of his own party has led to the electorate being asked to take a decision which looks increasingly likely to be made on the basis of a very shallow analysis with little thought about the sort of long term future we want to see.
To return to the lurid headline that I mentioned earlier, there actually is a sense in which the very future of Wales as a nation might depend on the outcome, although I don’t believe for a moment that it is what Hain and Vaughan – let alone the Western Mail’s headline writers – had in mind.  There is a huge difference between the sort of future we can have as a region of the EU (let alone if the aspirations of those of us who want to see Wales become a full member state come to pass) and the future we will have as a small periphery of an offshore island state.  It still doesn’t exactly challenge the continued existence of Wales, but it certainly makes a huge difference to what Wales actually is and can become.  The ‘national question’ is central to the debate, but is thus far hardly being mentioned.

Tuesday, 24 November 2015

Control of territory doesn't defeat an idea

Last week, the First Minister treated us to his views on the question of bombing Syria.  The first point he made – that there is no possibility of negotiation with ISIS - was entirely sound.  At the heart of their worldview is the certainty that they know what God’s will is, and that God wants them to impose his will on others.  It’s hard to see how there can be any scope for negotiating with divine will.
Carwyn Jones also called for a ‘plan’ for dealing with ISIS as a context for deciding on what if any military action should be taken.  Again, I entirely agree with that view.  A major part of the problems which the world faces in Libya, Syria, Iraq, and Afghanistan is that military intervention took place without any sort of a plan for the longer term. 
He didn’t tell us, though, what such a plan might look like.  In fairness, I can’t really blame him.  Although I’m equally certain that we need a plan, I don’t know what it might look like either.  But those of us who want a plan but won’t have much idea of what such a plan might be are far from being alone in the world.  The bigger problem is not that no-one really has a plan or knows where to start; it is that some people pretend they have a plan without being able to articulate it, whilst yet others, faced with the frustration of not knowing what to do simply fall back on military action as the ‘solution’.
For what it’s worth, I don’t actually doubt the sincerity of those arguing for a bombing campaign to attack ISIS in Syria as well as in Libya.  What I do doubt is the efficacy of that as an approach.  It seems to conflate military ‘victory’ with winning a war against an ideology.  There is no question in my mind that bombing ISIS can and will degrade their military capability on the ground; there is evidence already that the bombing campaign has helped the non-ISIS groups engaged in the war on the ground to regain territory.  But the battle isn’t really about territory at all.
A former director of the CIA was quoted in the Sunday Times as saying that “Their claim is that they are acting out the will of God … and nothing cuts against that narrative more than defeating them.”  I’m not sure that that actually displays very much understanding of the mindset behind ISIS, and without understanding their perspective rather better than that, progress is likely to be limited.  From their perspective, it isn’t a “claim”; they have an absolutely certain knowledge that they are implementing God’s will.  And from that perspective, military losses and setbacks are more likely to be interpreted as God testing their resolve than as a sign that they might be in any way misinterpreting God's will.
Yesterday, Cameron referred to ISIS as a ‘death cult’; others have talked about an ‘ideology of hate’ and used various other similar phrases.  It might be good for sound bites, but none of this shows any understanding of just how different a worldview we are dealing with.  Name-calling may help to justify sending in the bombers, but it doesn’t do much as a way of countering the ideology.
Over the last week, far too many politicians trying to appear responsible have said that they will “listen to” what Cameron has to say before deciding whether they will support a bombing campaign or not.  To an extent, that serves to legitimise the principle; the decision on whether to bomb or not becomes merely a matter of considering the detail.  No matter how careful or precise any campaign of bombing is, there will inevitably be civilian casualties.  And although the ideology which is the target will end up controlling less territory, it will probably emerge with a strengthened resolve and a more diffuse and even harder-to-tackle structure.  Not for the first time, we will end up failing to learn the lesson that the use of military might against an idea never really resolves anything in the long term.